PC Tools: Internet Security

During October, November and December 2010 we continuously evaluated 22 security products using their default settings. We always used the most current publicly-available version of all products for the testing. They were allowed to update themselves at any time and query their in-the-cloud services. We focused on realistic test scenarios and challenged the products against real-world threats. Products had to demonstrate their capabilities using all components and protection layers.

Protection Protection against malware infections (such as viruses, worms or Trojan horses)			Oct	Nov	Dec
Protection against 0-day malware attacks from the internet, inclusive of web and e-mail threats (Real-World Testing)	Industry average: 82 Samples used: 77	in %	92	100	94
Blocking of malware on or post execution (Dynamic Detection Testing)	Industry average: 55 Samples used: 20	in %	100
Detection of a representative set of malware discovered in the last 2-3 months (AV-TEST reference set)	Industry average: 96 Samples used: 642,693	in %	95	90	94
Detection of widespread malware (according to the WildList)	Industry average: 100 Samples used: 30,532	in %	100	100	100
Protection Score: 4.5/6.0

Repair Cleaning and repair of a malware-infected computer			Oct	Nov	Dec
Removal of all active components of widespread malware (according to the WildList) from a computer	Industry average: 82 Samples used: 22	in %	82
Removal of further malicious components and remediation of critical system modifications made by malware	Industry average: 45 Samples used: 22	in %	68
Detection of deliberately hidden active malware (Rootkits and stealth malware)	Industry average: 100 Samples used: 10	in %	100
Removal of deliberately hidden active malware (Rootkits and stealth malware)	Industry average: 60 Samples used: 10	in %	70
Repair Score: 4.5/6.0

Usability Impact of the security software on the usability of the whole computer (lower values indicate better results)			Oct	Nov	Dec
Average slow-down of the computer by the security software in daily use	Industry average: 221 Number of test cases: 13	in s	265
False detections of legitimate software as malware during a system scan (false positives)	Industry average: 7 Samples used: 533,690	in #	2	1	4
False warnings of certain actions during the installation and use of legitimate software	Industry average: 1 Samples used: 20	in #	3
False blockings of certain actions during the installation and use of legitimate software	Industry average: 1 Samples used: 20	in #	5
Usability Score: 3.5/6.0